Comparing shoes can be a tricky task. Even amongst similarly named shoes such as Oxfords and Derbys, there are many differences in the details. Whether you’re a fashion connoisseur or just trying to pick out the best pair of shoes to go with a nice suit or dress, it is important to know the differences between Oxford and Derby shoes. From the design, construction and formality of the two types of shoes to their comfort, cost and durability, there are plenty of differences to take into consideration. Step away from the push-button, automated shoe buying and get your feet back into the classics with a comparison of the two.

Defining the Key Features of Derby Shoes

Derby Shoes are full-cut shoes that feature an open lacing system. This means that instead of having two pieces that come together at a V-shape – like in most Oxfords – Derbies have a shallow V-shape formed by two pieces that make up the shoe roof open at the center. The “roof” has eyelets attached to it, creating an uninterrupted piece across the top of the foot. This lacing system creates a purposefully less structured and more relaxed look.

Exploring the Design of Oxfords

Oxfords feature a close-cut design and a closed lacing system. Rather than having two pieces that come together into an open V-shape, Oxfords have two flaps that overlap one another. They also feature eyelets along the wide side of this overlapping section, creating a single piece across the top of the foot. Aesthetically, the design creates a slimmer silhouette for the shoe, which can have a more modern look. In regards to comfort, these shoes tend to be quite stiff and less able to absorb pressure placed on the foot.

Understanding the Distinctions Between Oxford and Derby Shoes

The design distinction between Oxfords and Derbies is just one of several major differences between the two. Regarding formal wear, Oxfords usually find themselves being worn to much more formal occasions than Derbies. Whereas Oxfords feel at home in a tuxedo or other formalwear, Derbies feel more at ease in a casual setting. Additionally, Derbies generally offer more relaxed options in terms of color and other decoration options.

Assessing the Comfort of Derby and Oxford Shoes

Unsurprisingly, Derbies are much more comfortable than Oxfords. This is due to their better ability to absorb shock and flex around the foot. The closeness of the Oxford lacing can leave little room to maneuver and can actually produce a slight restriction around some of the areas of the foot not supported by its sturdy construction. In contrast, Derbies generally offer a much more comfortable experience, making them a great option for walking or other activities where comfort trumps formality.

Comparing Durability of Derby and Oxford Shoes

Depending on the materials used, both Derbies and Oxfords have potential for high durability. However, due to their slightly more simple design and sewing technique – when compared to Oxfords – Derbies offer a slight lift when it comes to durability and long-term use. The closed construction of an Oxford may fall prey to wear faster than its Derby counterpart.

Examining Formal Wear Potential of Derby and Oxford Shoes

When it comes to formalwear, Oxfords definitely have the edge over Derbies. Their close-cut design and overlapping flaps give them a much more modern and formal aesthetic. When combined with a suit or tuxedo and often with some kind of accent such as a buckle, they are sure to instill sophistication in any fashion-savvy man’s closet. While they can also be worn casually, they definitely have more potential when dressed up.

Evaluating Cost Differences Between Derby and Oxford Shoes

Derbies and Oxfords both come in different sizes and are crafted from different materials, making their cost differences difficult to measure. Generally, since an Oxford has a more intricate design and is often thought of as being higher quality, it may cost more than a Derby of equal quality. Due to the decreased cost associated with making a Derby, they have a tendency to be more affordable than their Oxford counterparts.

Comparing Styles of Derby and Oxford Shoes

Style wise, both Oxfords and Derbies offer unique takes on footwear classics and can make perfect additions to any sartorial closet. Whether you prefer the clean lines of an Oxford or enjoy the unique lacing system of a Derby, there is sure to be something out there that satisfies your particular style tastes. In terms of colors, Oxfords often come in dark shades which really bring out their traditional look while Derbies often come in lighter colors which can add an element of fun to any outfit.

Exploring the History Behind Derby and Oxford Shoes

Derbies are believed to have orginated in Ireland in the 19th century before then gaining ground in England and eventually making it over to America in the early 20th century. The design was created as an effort to mak footwear lighter in weight than traditional favorites such as work boots. On the other hand, Oxfords are believed to have originated from Scotland as early as 1800s but became popular amongst students at Oxford University in England in the 1850s; hence their name. As such, their usage naturally spread far and wide as students traveled back home.