When it comes to quality dress shoes, Allen Edmonds is always a name to consider. Whether you are looking for classic Oxford styles like the Carlyle Plain Toe or something more relaxed like the Strand lace-up, it is worth taking a minute to compare the two. In the following article we will discuss comfort, construction materials, and cost, so you can decide which shoe best meets your needs.
Overview of the Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford
The Allen Edmonds Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford is one of the company’s most iconic styles of shoes, and for good reason. The classic Oxford style with closed lacing is a go-to choice for dressy occasions, and the Comfortech Technology means that comfort does not have to be sacrificed for style. The sleek, handsome design of the Carlyle Plain Toe makes it the perfect shoe for almost any formal occasion.
The Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford is crafted from premium calfskin leather, which is both durable and stylish. The leather is also treated with a special wax finish to ensure that it will remain looking great for years to come. The leather is also lined with a soft, breathable fabric to keep your feet comfortable all day long. The sole is made from a lightweight rubber that provides excellent traction and shock absorption.
Overview of the Strand Lace-Ups
The Allen Edmonds Strand Lace-Up is a more relaxed version of the classic Oxford, designed to be comfortable and versatile. The open lacing makes it suitable for more casual settings, and the cushioned insole offers superior comfort. The Strand comes in three different leathers – black calf, cordovan calfskin, and suede – making it easy to find a style that suits your needs.
The Strand Lace-Ups are also designed with a Goodyear welt construction, which ensures that the shoes are durable and long-lasting. The leather upper is also treated with a special wax finish, which helps to protect the shoes from water and dirt. The Strand Lace-Ups are a great choice for those looking for a stylish and comfortable shoe that can be worn in a variety of settings.
Construction and Materials of the Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford
Like all Allen Edmonds shoes, the Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford is crafted from high quality materials. It features Genuine Leather uppers with a Goodyear-welted sole for enhanced durability. The cushioning footbed and Comfortech Technology help ensure a comfortable fit. The leather is available in black calf, dark mahogany, brown, and more.
Construction and Materials of the Strand Lace-Ups
The Strand Lace-Up is constructed with a Goodyear-welted sole and regular or reverse welt upper straps. It is available in black calf, cordovan calfskin, and suede. The midsole is cushioned for maximum comfort, and a leather footbed helps to provide additional support.
Comfort and Fit of the Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford
The Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford has a classic shape and Goodyear-welted construction, giving it self-molded fit. The Comfortech Technology helps to ensure an optimum fit around your feet. The leather upper and midsole provide added cushioning for better support.
Comfort and Fit of the Strand Lace-Ups
The Strand Lace-Up features open lacing for an easy fit. The midsole features cushioning for maximum comfort, while the footbed helps provide additional support. The additional cushioning ensures a more secure fit and less slipping.
Durability of the Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford
The Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford is made from high quality leathers, which not only look great but also help to ensure long-lasting wear. The Goodyear-welted sole and Comfortech Technology help add extra strength to the shoe, making it an excellent choice for the long haul.
Durability of the Strand Lace-Ups
The Strand Lace-Up is designed to provide long-lasting durability as well. Thanks to the high-quality materials used in its construction and the Goodyear-welted soles, you can be sure that it will stand up to wear and tear. The cushioning in the midsole also helps provide enhanced durability.
Cost Comparison of Allen Edmonds Oxfords and Strands
When it comes to cost, both shoes are on the pricey side. The Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford retails for around $360, while the Strand Lace-Up retails for around $350. For these higher prices you get access to superbly constructed shoes that should last many years with proper care.
Pros and Cons of Each Shoe
When it comes to deciding between the Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford and Strand Lace-Up, it really depends on the situation. The Carlyle is better suited for more formal occasions while the Strand is more relaxed. Both are designed with Comfortech Technology and Goodyear-welted soles for superior durability. Ultimately, it all depends on what type of look you prefer.
Conclusion
In conclusion, both of these Allen Edmonds shoes offer superior quality at an expensive price point. The Carlyle Plain Toe Oxford is a classic, timeless look perfect for formal occasions, while the Strand Lace-Up is more casual, but still provides great all day wearability. If you want quality dress shoes that will last, either shoe is an excellent choice.
