It can be tricky knowing which type of shoe is right to wear with a particular outfit. So, how can you decide whether an Oxford or a brogue is the better choice? Let’s take a look at their origins, styles, materials and construction, as well as some key differences to consider. We shall also cover how to know if either option is suitable for your outfit, how to care for either of these shoe types and how to make the best choice for your own wardrobe.
Origins of the Oxford and Brogue
The Oxford shoe has a long and interesting heritage, stretching back to the mid-19th century. They originally began as a dressier alternative to the plainer working shoes of that time. Students at the University of Oxford were among the first to wear them, leading to the shoe’s name.
Much more recently, the brogue was created in Ireland in the late 1800s, when the traditional peasant shoe was given shallow cuts which showed multicolored leather underneath. Today it maintains that slightly rustic look.
The Oxford and Brogue have become popular in many different countries, and are now seen as a classic style of shoe. They are often worn with formal attire, but can also be dressed down for a more casual look. The Oxford and Brogue are a timeless style that will never go out of fashion.
Styles of the Oxford and Brogue
The Oxford’s sophisticated look comes from its neat, straight lines. It usually features lacing, along with a cap toe (rounded at the front). The style has evolved over the years, however some of the dressier versions still retain the classic shape.
The brogue has wingtips along the outside edge of its uppers, giving it a stylish flair. It usually has perforated patterns, along with its wingtips. It’s available in two toe designs – rounded or pointed. This allows you to choose from either a more casual or dressier version of this shoe.
Construction of an Oxford and Brogue
The Oxford is constructed using a closed lacing system with a single piece of leather stitched across the vamp (distance between opening and lacing up). This method gives it a sharp, slimline silhouette.
The brogue on the other hand is shaped with an open lacing system that allows room for a bit more toe room. Also, it has a good arch support, which helps give it more flexibility compared to the Oxford.
Materials Used for Oxfords and Brogues
Oxfords are typically made from leather (or synthetic leather), including calfskin, kidskin and vici kid. The stitching and lacing are usually made from a strong thread like linen or waxed cotton.
Brogue shoes are commonly crafted from leather and suede, although some models also offer synthetic materials. The lacing is usually made from leather or cotton.
Identifying Key Differences between Oxfords and Brogues
The most obvious difference between an Oxford and a brogue is their construction – an Oxford has closed lacing whereas a brogue has open lacing. Oxfords tend to offer a silkier, smoother look than their brogue counterparts which have intricate textures and patterns due to their wingtip design.
When it comes to formality, Oxfords are generally dressier than brogues. This might not be the case for certain designs though, so make sure you always check with each individual style.
Suiting an Oxford or a Brogue to Your Outfit
When it comes to choosing between an Oxford or brogue shoe, you first have to decide which shoe is best suited to the occasion. If you are dressing formally, then an Oxford is probably your best bet.
However if you’re planning to dress more casually then, a brogue might be your best option. Brogues also look great when teamed with a tailored trouser or chic skirt.
Taking Care of Your Oxfords and Brogues
Caring for both oxfords and brogues starts with ensuring the uppers are regularly dusted, which can be done with just a soft microfiber cloth. You can also use polish or cream to nourish your shoes, however it’s important to remember that some darker colours may fade if you use too much polish or cream.
You should also ensure that your Oxfords or Brogues are stored correctly to avoid creasing. Try storing in an upright position so that gravity doesn’t affect their shape or store in shoe trees for extra support.
Conclusion: Choosing the Right Shoe for You
Knowing which type of shoe is right for your particular outfit and occasion can be tricky but understanding what separates an Oxford from a Brogue means you will never go wrong. The straight lines and sleek silhouette of an Oxford make it perfect to wear with formal attire while brogues have a more casual appeal perfect for day-to-day wear.
Ultimately you should make sure you keep an eye on both the styling and construction when selecting an Oxford or Brogue. Only then you can make sure you get the perfect combination of sleek style and reliable support for all your shoe-wearing needs!
