Few shoe styles have stood the test of time as well as plain brogues and oxfords. While both have a distinctive aesthetic and slightly different construction, there are several stark differences that must be considered when choosing between the two. From the toe cap to the choice of material, let’s take a look at the differences between plain brogues and oxfords and what to look out for when selecting the perfect shoe for any occasion.
What Are Plain Brogues?
Plain brogues trace their origins back to Scotland and Ireland in the early 20th century. This classic style of shoe is often characterized by low profile lacing with a series of decorative intricate punching. Most commonly made from leather, plain brogues feature a signature brogue pattern along the toe, side cutouts, and toe caps. These shoes are best known for appearing at semi-formal events, job interviews, and can even be worn with a casual outfit.
Plain brogues are a timeless style of shoe that can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. They are a great choice for those looking for a versatile shoe that can be worn for a variety of occasions. Plain brogues are also a great choice for those looking for a comfortable shoe that can be worn all day. With proper care, plain brogues can last for years, making them a great investment for any wardrobe.
What Are Oxfords?
Oxfords, on the other hand, are a slightly more formal variation of the brogue. These shoes are characterized by their closed lacing system, working from a low top-line to a pointed toe. While Made from leather or suede, oxfords generally feature fewer decorative elements than their brogue siblings. This makes them a more formal style of shoe, perfect for more sophisticated events like weddings, galas and other black-tie events.
Oxfords are a timeless classic, and can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. They can be paired with a suit for a formal look, or with jeans and a blazer for a more casual look. They are also a great choice for the office, as they are comfortable and stylish. No matter the occasion, oxfords are sure to make a statement.
The Difference in Design
The primary design difference between these two types of shoes lies in their lacing systems. Plain brogues feature an open lacing system that allows the shoe to have cutouts along the edges. This makes them more comfortable and gives them a casual, laidback look. Oxfords have a closed-lacing system that creates a seamless aesthetic with the shoe tongue visible at all times. This gives them a more formal look that won’t be out of place at special events.
The Toe Cap of the Shoe
The toe caps on both brogues and oxfords can vary significantly in terms of style and design. Some brogues feature pointed toe caps, while some oxfords can have a more rounded shape. These subtle differences can help add a unique flair to any outfit, no matter if it is plain or formal. Pay close attention to this design element when making your final selection.
The Difference in Comfort
In terms of comfort, plain brogues may be slightly more comfortable than oxfords due to their open lacing system. Additionally, some brogue designs feature cushioned footbeds or insoles that can make them even more comfortable to wear throughout the day. Oxfords usually feature stiffer soles that may take some getting used to before they feel comfortable on your feet.
How to Choose Between Plain Brogues and Oxfords
Now that you’re familiar with the differences between these two iconic styles of shoes, it’s time to decide which will work best for you. The choice between a brogue and an oxford will largely depend on the occasion you plan to attend. If attending a casual event such as a backyard barbecue or semi-formal gathering then a plain brogue should fit perfectly into the dress code. Conversely, if attending an elegant wedding or formal event then an oxford will be more appropriate.
Deciding on Style and Occasion
When selecting a shoe for any event, it’s important to consider the overall style of the outfit you’ll be wearing in addition to the occasion. For example, it may look strange to wear a plain brogue with a tuxedo or an oxford with jeans and a t-shirt. Likewise, it pays to match the material of the shoe to other aspects of your dress code such as a belt or tie.
Tips for Choosing the Right Shoes
When shopping for shoes online or in-store, be sure to take accurate measurements to ensure the perfect fit. Take into account that both brogues and oxfords tend to run slightly large, so you may wish to order a size smaller than what your measurement may indicate. Lastly, if possible try on several different models for a better sense of how each type of shoe fits you.
